Salt water from some of the giant pools and related
plumbing at SeaWorld Orlando and neighboring Discovery Cove has been
leaking into the aquifer, beneath those theme parks, in some cases for
seven years or more, according to state environmental records.
The salt-contaminated groundwater is not particularly toxic, but some
samples drawn from monitoring wells at the two parks are nearly as
salty as seawater. Those tests, disclosed midday Friday by the Orlando
Sentinel on its Web site, also produced samples with the acidity of
orange juice or even vinegar.
In the most recent tests on file with the Florida Department of
Environmental Protection, 24 of 42 wells produced water exceeding
federal drinking-water standards for chloride, sodium, sulfates or
other contaminants. Seven of those wells had more than 10 times as much
sodium and chloride as federal standards allow.
With one exception, there is no indication the slow-moving contamination has spread beyond the theme parks' borders.
There also appears to be little risk that the salty groundwater, which
is limited to the "surficial," or near-surface, aquifer, will wind up
in someone's drinking water, normally drawn from the state's deep
aquifer. And there is no evidence the saltwater has seeped yet into
nearby freshwater ponds or the canals that drain the area before
flowing into Shingle Creek, one of the headwaters of the Everglades.
Still, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, while
expressing confidence that no significant harm will occur to humans or
the environment, wants to make sure it is correct. The agency has asked
SeaWorld to install dozens of additional groundwater-monitoring wells,
to sample nearby ponds weekly for contamination and to pump
contaminated water out of the ground before it can spread.
Government regulations forbid companies from degrading any groundwater,
whether deep in the earth or near the surface, to levels below
drinking-water standards, because that water could one day be needed
for human consumption.
"The department considers any contamination to Florida's groundwater or
surface waters a serious matter," DEP spokesman Jeff Prather said
Friday.
At Discovery Cove -- a high-end, resort-style theme park that opened in
the summer of 2000 -- the leaks appear to have come from the coral-reef
lagoon and two saltwater holding ponds. One of the ponds has been
closed, repairs have been made to the lagoon, and park officials think
the situation is improving. But the park has also installed wells to
extract salty water from the ground before it reaches a nearby canal or
another pond, and a company official said a long-term solution would
take several years.
Kelly Bernish, SeaWorld's director of environmental health and safety,
said Friday that any threat to the environment should diminish as the
slow-moving groundwater spreads and becomes more diluted, and as
SeaWorld's efforts to solve the problem continue.
"We have a long history of caring for the environment, and certainly we
took immediate action as soon as we saw there was any issue at hand,"
she said.
The leaks inside SeaWorld involved specific, isolated incidents that
were quickly fixed and are now under control, Bernish said. Those leaks
occurred in the Shamu Stadium filtration-plant system, which is in an
employee-only area at the south end of the park, and in a system of
dolphin-isolation pools that is mostly in an employee-only area at the
park's north end.
But the state DEP is not so sure the situation inside SeaWorld is under control.
Agency officials suggested in December internal memos that they suspect
multiple leaks have occurred in the Shamu Stadium filtration system,
and that both those and the leaks in the dolphin-isolation pools are
neither contained nor well-defined yet.
Bernish was surprised when asked about those state assessments.
"As for any concerns that have been communicated to us in our quarterly
or more frequent meetings, we have always reached consensus and carried
out those strategies and directives cooperatively," she said.
Bernish said the leaks posed little threat to the environment. She
characterized the problems as regulatory in nature, involving technical
standards.
"We have absolutely no indication this would affect any animal or plant
life in the region," she said. "It hasn't on our property. And as you
know, the grounds at both of our parks are very lush and landscaped,
and we haven't had any indications of any problems."
Detected in 2000
The saltwater problem was detected in early 2000, when SeaWorld --
operated by Busch Entertainment Corp., a wholly owned subsidiary of
beer maker Anheuser-Busch Cos. -- was preparing to open Discovery Cove.
After crews filled the coral-reef lagoon, they discovered the giant
pool was losing about an inch of salt water a day.
Since then, leaks have been detected and more wells
have been installed, and contaminated groundwater has been found in
several locations at both Discovery Cove and SeaWorld. The only
off-site contamination suspected at this time is beneath an Orange
County fire station on land next to Discovery Cove. Tests have not yet
been conducted there, but groundwater drawn from wells just across the
property line was tainted with salt.
Most of the monitoring efforts have been under way for several years.
In July, DEP Central District Director Vivian F. Garfein, in a letter
to Bernish, said it was time for "more aggressive efforts for
addressing these saltwater releases and their associated impacts on the
groundwater and surface-water resources." That included a call to
intensify some of the monitoring.
In a written statement, Prather said Friday that Garfein called for
heightened efforts because both Discovery Cove and SeaWorld continued
to report saltwater releases. Prather said long-term plans for handling
the problem cannot be determined until the extent of the contamination
is fully understood.
"The facilities will need to continue to assess the extent of
contamination in the groundwater and develop a strategy to either
remediate the contamination or ensure no further migration from its
existing location," he said.
Forty-two active groundwater-monitoring wells now pepper the SeaWorld
and Discovery Cove properties. The acidity of the salty water, as
measured by the 0-14 pH scale, has ranged as low as 5.53 in the
dolphin-isolation pools, 3.61 in Discovery Cove and 3.64 in the Shamu
Stadium filtration system -- all below the regulatory limits of 6.5 to
8.5 pH.
But the main contaminants are sodium and chloride, two ions that
combine to make table salt, and sulfate, another salt common to
seawater.
Contamination levels in many of the Discovery Cove wells have fallen
steadily through several testing periods, particularly those near the
east and west holding ponds, according to DEP documents. Likewise, most
of the recent samples taken near SeaWorld's dolphin-isolation pools
were better than those taken in some preliminary tests last spring.
But several wells near Discovery Cove's coral-reef lagoon got worse last year.
The problems with Discovery Cove's holding ponds "are decreasing and,
in fact, we have asked the DEP to abandon some of those wells, because
it is looking so good," Bernish said. "The coral-reef water is moving
very slowly, and we're continuing to monitor and remediate there."
Contaminated samples have come from several wells along the property
line between Discovery Cove and the Orange County fire station, which
is on land donated to the county by SeaWorld.
DEP officials expect to find contaminated water under the county-owned
site as well, and have requested that wells be installed there. County
official have not yet consented, they said.